Review: Agnes Grey

Back to the Classics Challenge 2012(I read this book as part of the Back to the Classics Challenge. Click on the link or image to join in the fun!)

When her family’s financial situation becomes impossible, the young Agnes Grey hires herself out as a governess. The families for whom she works and the children she teaches are uniformly terrible, and it is only through persistence, patience, and a kind heart that Agnes is able to continue earning money for her family.

But will the kind preacher for whom she cares ever truly see her, or will Agnes’ good heart and inner loveliness be overshadowed by the flirtatiousness and beauty of her newest student?

Some thoughts

While I adore Charlotte’s Jane Eyre and despise Emily’s Wuthering Heights, the third sister (Anne Brontë) and her novel Agnes Grey fall somewhere in between.

It’s not that the book was bad; it just felt like a poor imitation of Jane Eyre: a poor and plain governess comes to teach for a wealthy family; falls in love; trials and tribulations; obstacles, and ultimate success.

The story wasn’t a long one (681 ebook pages), but it felt too long. The time Agnes spends as a governess to the first family, the Bloomfields, for example. It went on for 120 pages, even though Bronte could have easily gotten the themes and ideas across in much less, or by removing that section altogether. The time Agnes spends with the second family is more than enough to showcase those themes (how governesses are abused, how parents are over-indulgent, how servants are treated badly, etc.).

The main character felt flat. I wanted to feel worse for her, but she didn’t give me much reason to like her. Unlike Charlotte’s Jane, Anne’s Agnes has no real spine, no bravery. She’s just kind of mousy and well-behaved, and refuses to stand up for herself in any real way.

Brontë got her message across: I hated the characters I was supposed to hate, and rooted for those for whom I was supposed to. But in the end I didn’t really care that much — there was never much tension, because I knew from the start that Agnes would end up happily married. It took the zing out of the reading.

I’m glad I read this book, but I won’t say I enjoyed it much.

Challenge credit

Published in 1847, Anne Brontë’s Agnes Grey fulfills the credit for a 19th century classic read.

Am I totally off the mark here? What do you think of the Brontë sisters’ writings?

Like this post? Share it!

4 thoughts on “Review: Agnes Grey

  1. I’m not a huge fan of Wuthering Heights and, I’m sorry, but I HATE Jane Eyre. I wanted to read this one to see what I thought of the other Bronte sister. One day I’ll get to it.

    1. Aw, I’m sad you don’t like Jane Eyre. It’s been one of my favorites since I first read it in high school.

      Wuthering Heights, though, ugh. That’s time I’ll never get back! :p

      I need to give Anne’s other book, The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, a chance. I’ve heard good things, including that it’s considered the first feminist novel, so I’m inclined to like it already.

  2. How timely: An acquaintance just gushed to me about Agnes Grey, and your review offers a point of balance plus the intimation that I could probably get this novel for free on the iPad. Off to check it out!
    Thanks for the heads-up about your new blogspace: Looking good!

    1. I’m glad to offer a balanced review for you to compare. And yes, I got it for free using the iBook app on my phone. The Gutenberg Project puts out a lot of free versions of classics.

      Yay for new blog! I’m so glad to have everything transferred over and (mostly) looking good.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.